patching...
Breaking: Lt. Gov. Tim Murray to Resign »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

UPDATED: Arrests Made in 1969 Murder Case

Three men are identified in connection with the 1969 murder of John McCabe.

 

A break has been made in a cold case murder that has been hanging over Tewksbury for 41 years. 

The Middlesex District Attorney's Office announced this morning the arrests Edward Alan Brown, 59, of Londonberry, NH, Walter Shelley, 60, of Tewksbury, and Michael Ferreira, 57, of Salem, NH. 

Brown and Shelley were arraigned in Lowell District Court before Judge Harvey Friday morning. Shelley was ordered held on $500,000 cash bail. Brown was released on personal recognizance.  Their next court date is May 26 for a pre-trial conference.

Ferreira was arraigned in Exeter District Court in New Hampshire on the fugitive from justice warrant and was ordered held on $500,000 cash bail. He faces a rendition hearing in Salem District Court on Monday, April 18 at 9 a.m. He will be arraigned on the juvenile murder complaint upon his rendition to Massachusetts.

 “After many decades of frustration, the exceptional efforts and dedication of the Lowell Police, the Massachusetts State Police, the Tewksbury Police and the Middlesex DA's Office have paid off.  This truly is a remarkable story and much credit is due to Mr. William McCabe, the father of John McCabe, and the entire McCabe family," Lowell Police Superintendent Lavallee said. 

"Their determination to see this matter resolved motivated all of us in law enforcement to keep this matter on the front burner. I also applaud all the detectives who worked this case and in particular, Detective Gerry Wayne of the Lowell Police Dept. His investigatory efforts formed much of the basis for the successful resolution of this matter. Unfortunately Detective Wayne succumbed to cancer in 2009 and is not here to see his efforts come to fruition."

Shelley is charged with murder. Brown is charged with manslaughter. Because Ferreira was a juvenile at the time of the incident, he will be charged in juvenile court on the murder charge and will face an adult complaint on a perjury charge for lying to the Grand Jury. Ferreira will first face a fugitive from justice warrant in New Hampshire prior to facing the Massachusetts charges

McCabe's body was found in a field off of Maple Street in Lowell on the morning of Sept. 27, 1969. McCabe had disappeared after leaving a dance in Tewksbury. The teen was found bound with rope and with signs of torture.

The District Attorney's office said it is alleged that Shelley, Ferreira and Brown were all involved in abducting the victim and holding him in a car against his will where they assaulted him, and subsequently bound and gagged him in such a way that it led to his death.   

It is alleged that Shelley drove the car to the vacant field on Maple Street in Lowell and that the defendants left the victim in the field, where he died alone, the DA said. 

The cause of death was determined to be asphyxia due to strangulation. 

Friends Forever 

Friday morning McCabe's friends Carol "Maggie" Coffey, Paul Antonelli and Robert Poulin, who had been hounding the Lowell and State Police since their friend's murder, rejoiced.

"My heart is just pounding," Coffey said. 

Coffey was the girl who was supposed to meet McCabe at the dance that night until her mother made her stay in and clean her room.

"He was in my art class and had drawn this beautiful 'make love, not war, poster," Coffey remembered. "He approached me and asked me to go to the dance that night. I was so thrilled that a boy noticed me."

Coffey said since that night, she never forgot McCabe or allowed his death to grow cold in her own mind.

"His friends never forgot him," Coffey said noting Antonelli and Poulin worked with her to garner the attention of local police departments. "We wanted this to be solved for his parents. Forty-one years is too long, especially when everyone in town at the time had suspicions about who did it."

The irony of the situation, Coffey said, is that McCabe's parents never even knew she and their son's old friends were pushing for the case to be solved the whole time.

"I knew this day would come because I insisted it come," Coffey said. "I would have accepting nothing other than this day coming. Our goal was to have this case solved while John's parents were still alive."

That Red Headed Boy

To McCabe's friends, his death was more than just a loss of a friend and talented student. It was the end of their innocence.

"It was the 70s drug days and a lot of kids died in Tewksbury of overdoses, and boys were coming home from the war," Coffey said. "But John was the first one of us."

Coffey said she and others in town knew there were witnesses who saw McCabe get into a car with someone that night, but no one came forward.

"There was an intact crime scene, DNA from the crime scene and witnesses, but they couldn't find the person who did this?" Coffey said. "I'm not out to see someone go to jail; I just didn't want 41 years to go by when everyone knew the essentials of what had happened."

Today, Coffey said she is remembering the red headed, freckled kid from art class and will pin a ribbon on the black and white picture of John that has been hanging over her desk. 

"It was John's friends who never forgot," Coffey said. "The machine may have solved the case but we weren't giving up."

Related Topics: 1969 murder, Cold Case, cold case murder, and walter shelley

denise

11:36 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

I am so sad to hear of this...but happy that justice will be served. Sorry for the loss of your friend.

Maggie Coffey

11:45 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

Captain Jonathan Webb was the poor cop who put up with the incessant emails and questions. He could have turned a deaf ear, but he listened and responded to me, even though I remained the "squeaky wheel" in this wonderful turn of events. But truly, it was John himself that remained unforgettable. Thanks to Pou and Paul for supplying the grease. Carol "Maggie" Coffey - friend, classmate of John.

Comment_arrow

caesd4

1:40 pm on Sunday, April 17, 2011

Hey Carol, How did you get him to confess?

John

12:00 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

Maggie,

41 Years is quite a long time to wait for this outcome... Your friend John McCabe would be very proud to stand along side you and call you his friend

I am very impressed by the tenacity that you and others showed never giving up

Kathleen Brothers

1:07 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

Maggie, I too congratulate you and your friends for never giving up. I remember the time well. I heard it on the news that morning. It was a heart wrenching story. Thanks to all the Police, Johns' Friends and to the McCabe Family for NEVER giving up. God Bless, John and God Bless you all.

Bucky

1:40 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

These three Murderers have been living the Adult Life 42, 41 and 40 years. There should be no standards of conduct implied or imposed. They caused the end of a life for a Child. This was not self-defense...This was an act that took great effort to create. This was not bulling, this was not teaching him a lesson. This was not meeting outside the school to settle a jealous situation. Face to face fist to fist this was the act of cowards that needed restraints to prove how tough they were. I knew the family in the early 1970’s spent time with Mr. and Mrs. McCabe, Debbie and Roberta. Those three MURDERERS put a whole lot of hurting on that family. Jail really is to serine and environment for Shelley, Brown and Ferreira ..

George

2:02 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

41 years...their consciences didn't bother them at all for 41 years? How can a person live that long with themselves knowing that they, allegedly, killed another person? It's amazing that cases like this find resolution after such a long period of time.

Elaine M Dunn

2:44 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

I was just a young kid when this murder hit the Sun......I remember being afraid. I loved that little town and until this day I always wondered if his murder would ever be solved. Unfortunately we were moved up to NH 2 years after John's murder.....I still go down to Tewksbury and drive through my old home town. I am generally suspicious of local police investigations due to their many clumsy investigations. Kudos to the officers that gave this man's family justice. May they rot in prison for taking such a young precious life for such s stupid and gratuitous reason.......not that murder is ever the answer......to any conflicts. May he R I P. I guess they were able to live all these years because neither one had a soul.......Prison will be their much needed pay back......if they had kids....and families those two me will suffer even more......you know what they say about the "pay back". I feel sorry for these two thugs family members. There are so many victims when a murder is committed.

denise

6:24 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

this story has been on my mind all day...what did these guys go on and live their lives? I feel bad for the families of these 3 also. I am glad i dont know them.

tbird

6:50 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

who keep going on this case deserves a medal, and a big pat on the back, what people we still have in law enforcement makes you feel reel good i lived in tewksbury for 35 years ans always felt safe nice going thanks who ever you are.

Salon1475

11:31 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

Such a sad story but so glad justice will finally be served. To the McCabe family and friends that kept fighting for justice for John, great job! To all the officers and detectives that worked on this case, thank you for all that you do!

PAA

7:13 am on Saturday, April 16, 2011

Maggie deserves major credit for this. The girl is relentless.

Linda Rea

9:30 am on Saturday, April 16, 2011

Shame on anyone who witnessed him getting into that car and could have solved this case back when. There should be no bale or trial. just through the bumbs in jail and let them rot. We should have the death sentance for this.

kevin o'keefe

10:29 am on Sunday, April 17, 2011

Wow I just got a very cold chill come over me.time goes by life goes on.I can remember it like yesterday. .more thanks thanks maggie than words can say.he should have graduated with us instead he's smiling down on us.

Comment_arrow

Maggie Coffey

8:00 am on Friday, June 3, 2011

Dear Kevin - it is so nice to have your kind words. I am getting attacked by some real armchair quarterbacks, questioning who I am and whether I knew John! One, named Jackson, has been especially spiteful just because he does not remember me, and has made efforts to convince John's parents I am some sort of fraud - although I don't know what gain would ever come of it! All I did was keep trying over many years, to get answers by writing and calling people and coordinating contacts. Now, I am under attack for it. So thank you, just for the kindness. Carol Maggie Coffey

tbird

5:55 pm on Thursday, April 21, 2011

THEY ALL SHOULD BE CHARGED WITH MURDER.

jackson

8:23 pm on Tuesday, May 17, 2011

First and fore most, I would like to start with the Officials, Mr. McCabe and Mrs. McCabe know who the individual was that helped in solving their son John's Murder. They would like to remain anonymous and behind the scenes. So, with that being stated, for those who are taking credit for something they have no idea or the real facts should remain silent and stop taking credit for something they had no hand in solving this murder case! Stay tuned for the facts...FACTS

Donna J. Rhynd

4:26 pm on Thursday, May 26, 2011

My heart and prayers go out to Mrs and Mr McCabe. I grew up with Johnny when we were still in diapers and I lived on Linwood St and they lived on Foster Road. I have never forgotten him and although I know this may be some closure for the McAaves the hole in their hearts will always remain. My love and my prayers go out to you...........Love and peace Donna Rhynd

Maggie Coffey

7:27 am on Friday, May 27, 2011

Just for the record, NONE of John's friends are taking credit for SOLVING this murder! I'll speak for myself: FORTY ONE YEARS is just too long to solve a case. What I will take some credit for is this: Calling the police, emailing them, starting a dialogue, keeping it going, never forgetting, NOT giving up, even when IGNORED by the police AND the GOVERNOR's office:: constacting TV shows: If this crap keeps up, I'll start publishing the emails I have to and from them! Anyone who did not do at least that should shut up. Yeah, the cops FINALLY got it solved, and they deserve all the back patting - but I firmly believe they would have taken another 41 years if they had not been CONSTANTLY PRODDED - by people who loved and missed John and would NOT accept the cops taking 41 years to solve this case. Read the recent article: Because the 3 killers denied it!?!?! They FLUNKED polygraphs 41 years ago! Whatever the cops did to solve this, they should have done during any one of those 41 years. John's family called them constantly to stay on the case and with tips: John's friends stayed loyal to the family and John and insisted on answers, WHY DID THEY HAVE TO? Believe me, the cops would still be sitting at their desks if they weren't getting CONSTANT PRESSURE to get off their collective asses. We even requested the case file to put a private homicide investigator on it : they refused! State and local police needed FORTY ONE YEARS!?!?!

Maggie Coffey

7:45 am on Friday, May 27, 2011

Hey CAESD$: According to court records, Ferreira and Shelley were considered prime suspects from the outset of the investigation, having given investigators conflicting stories about their activities and having failed polygraph tests. However, police allege the trio made a vow of silence, never to discuss the case.

For that reason, the case remained unsolved for decades. A tip in 2008 resulted in a Grand Jury being convened and Fereira being called to testify. He denied any involvement in the murder and denied any knowledge of what happened to Johnny McCabe.

WHAT DID YOU DO TO HELP CAESD4? ANYTHING?!?!?! HELLO!?!?!?! I did NOT solve this case and NEVER said I did, but I also did not sit on my ass and allow another 41 years to go by - at least I did SOMETHING!

Maggie Coffey

8:02 am on Friday, May 27, 2011

"However, police allege the trio made a vow of silence, never to discuss the case.
For that reason, the case remained unsolved for decades."

So all it takes to escape justice for 41 years is to simply say, "Let's not tell the cops we did it, okay?" Brilliant! I wonder how the jails ever got so full! All those prisoners must have failed to think up such a brilliant evasion method, poor stupid things.

Wonder what would have happened if the murders had been subjected to a little more pressure? Me too! THAT's why I put it on Topix, on Classmates.com, contacted the State Police, the Governor (who ignored the emails PLEADING for action) and the Lowell and Tewks. PD... asking for a QUALIFIED homicide investigator to review the file; and copied the letters sent to T.V. shows and sent them along to them, too. I definitely did NOT solve this case - but I definitely insisted that SOMEONE should solve it. Now they have. Finally. After 41 years. Good job. I don't know if breathing down their necks and threatening publicity helped at all... but it sure didn't hurt. So to anyone saying I am in this for the glory or publicity - where were you when we were taking time from our own lives to do something positive, armchair quaterback? Next time, coward, publish your complaints with your full name - like I have.... or shut up and get back in your lounge armchair. No guts?

Comment_arrow

jackson

10:34 pm on Thursday, June 2, 2011

Jack Ward

Normally, I wouldn't dignify this with any sort of a response! Due to the fact, that I wouldn't desacrate this site or John's family or John!!! I sent my reply to your web site A&E! Your response was done in poor taste nor tact!

Maggie Coffey

8:20 am on Friday, May 27, 2011

HEY JACKSON: "It was John's friends who never forgot," Coffey said. "The machine may have solved the case but we weren't giving up."

We, too, were anonymous - myself, for about 12 years, and others for the past 3. Not until the arrests were made and Capt. Jon Webb called me to tell me (as he had two weeks before, to tell me it was going to happen) did the press contact me because they saw the TOPIX thread I started. NOBODY did anything for any other reason but this: 41 years is TOO LONG! It needed to be solved, and it needed to be solved in John's parents' lifetimes. THAT was the SINGULAR motive. You want facts? Give your whole name and I'll send you some emails that will enlighten you a little. THERE WERE MANY PEOPLE WORKING ANONYMOUSLY ON THIS FOR SEVERAL YEARS - Not just the ONE you know about. Where were you? We could have used your help since you seem to know so much. I am clearly getting a little sick and tired of taking abuse from armchair quarterbacks for doing something that HELPED. No good deed goes unpunished, right? I've never sought glory, publicity, or even a kind thank you - But I will NOT be slammed for doing what I did. And I will NOT have my motives, or the motives of anyone who came forward and helped me, questioned by ANYONE without biting back, so be LIKE ME and have the courage of your convictions... or go away and be quiet AGAIN. I never did.

Maggie Coffey

8:27 am on Friday, May 27, 2011

From: magicoffey@live.comSent: 9/12/2010 11:43:28 AMTo: "Webmail, Gov (GOV)" <Gov.Webmail@state.ma.us>Cc: Subject: EmailComment UNSOLVED MURDER OF JOHN McCABE Why, after 41 years, is this case still unsolved, although a CHILD was MURDERED, and there was a CRIME SCENE. Five people failed polygraphs, two more refused. The Lowell and State Police have had 41 YEARS!So, I am now wondering if America's Most Wanted, or Unsolved Mysteries, or 48 Hours Mysteries, or 20/20, or some such vehicle might spark some activity. It is simply untenable that a person or persons MURDERED THIS CHILD and left a crime scene behind, yet there is no answer as yet as to who did it. We are not dealing with criminal masterminds here - just small town hoodlums and bullies.I wonder if an FBI profiler, or a private investigator, or even a psychic (out of sheer desperation after 40 years!) were ever employed to fill in the gaps necessary to solve this young boy's murder?Lowell Police Capt. Webb informed me that he would be meeting with the State Police Investigator assigned to this case and would try to renew efforts to gain some ground. While no one is interested in impeding the police, it seems there is no way to impede something that is static anyway, and, as stated to Webb, there are several people - no longer resourceless children like our classmate John McCabe - who are more than interested in finding a solution to this case. We are not going away. CONTINUED

Maggie Coffey

8:28 am on Friday, May 27, 2011

Ideally, Lowell P.D. would solve this crime. That would, after all this time and effort on their part, be wonderful! If, however, those law enforcement agencies are stymied, why wouldn't you accept help in the form of a private investigator, retired FBI profiler, or even, dare I say it, a psychic. ANYTHING is better than NOTHING. They've had 41 years... how bout admitting you could use a little help to SOLVE this crime?C. Maggie Coffey [This one was ignored, so see next post where I had to write again, and mention VOTERS)

Maggie Coffey

8:33 am on Friday, May 27, 2011

SENT TO GOVERNOR PATRICK WHEN THE FIRST EMAILS (POSTED ABOVE) GOT NO ACTION (NOTE DATES):

From: "Maggie Coffey" <magicoffey@live.com>
> Sent: 9/17/2010 9:05:01 AM
> To: "Webmail, Gov (GOV)" <Gov.Webmail@state.ma.us>
> Cc:
> Subject: Unsolved HOMICIDE of Child
>
>
> Governor Patrick,
>
> May I please, at your convenience, have your response to this email?
>
> Thank you in advance for your kind attention to this very serious matter.
>
> Respectfully,
> Maggie Coffey
> P.S. Although I am no longer a resident of Massachusetts, my families (The Mattuchios, the Coffeys and the Catalanos) all still live there, and I am hoping that you will consider me a constituent by proxy and therefore allow this respectful begging of your attention.
>
>

Maggie Coffey

7:55 am on Friday, June 3, 2011

jackson - FIRST of all, idiot, learn to read and spell - NEVER said I was one of John's friends or met his parents or anything like that - just said I knew him from art class and he asked me if I was going to the dance that night. You must be a TMHS graduate! ALSO, IF you were such a best friend, PLEASE tell us ALL what you did to help in this case! Anything? Ever? Maybe that is where YOUR guilt is coming from? Yeah, hung out with Diane and vaguely remember Marianne - I was very popular with lots of kids: Donna Cordiero, Charlotte Earle, Robin Kelly, Leo, Pou, the Cormiers, Smitty and Murph, Micky, Bobbie, Marty Finnegan, many, many, many more and guess what? I DON'T remember you.... you must have been a real idiot then, too! Stop attacking ME for what YOU failed to do: Remember John and DO SOMETHING to HELP. Moron. You can't even spell CAROL right. Armchair quarterback in after everything is DONE by SOMEONE besides You! John asked me to meet him at the dance the night he was killed, never lived long enough to mention me to his parents and, so what? THEY HAVE THE PAINTING HE MADE FOR ME - What did he make for YOU, best buddy? Why did you NEVER contact the MANY people who helped? Huh? Huh?

Maggie Coffey

8:38 am on Friday, June 3, 2011

jackwad - how DARE you tell anyone to bother the McCabe family to find out who you are? You should be ashamed for attaching yourself to them like that - have you no heart? Using them to further your own purpose is dispicable. Now we all know who you are, and what you are... jackwad. If you were really a friend of the family, you would show the kind of courage and class they have for all these years and stop using these sad events to make yourself feel better for doing N-O-T-H-I-N-G for 41 years and suddendly showing up a day late and a dollar short to claim best friend status.... what a worm you are! A cowardly, self-promoting, name-dropping, useless, guilt-ridden worm.... and hearing anything out of your mouth from here on out will PROVE that! Why not just get yourself a T-shirt that says: I am John's best friend - even though I did NOTHING for him EVER except show up at the last minute and cause a lot of drama. Idiot.

Maggie Coffey

8:48 am on Friday, June 3, 2011

P.S. The reason John's family never heard of me until this case broke is that I, and the other friends helping, specifically Robert Poulin and Paul Antonelli, had the grace to NOT contact or bother the family while we worked quietly behind the scenes. Out of respect, care and concern that we not upset them until and unless we had something positive to say, we did NOT contact them... it would have been crass to do so. But, for any doubters like "jackwad" - my emails and contacts to and from the police, the governor, T.V. shows, Topix, Classmates.com go back to 2010, 2009, 2008, 1997.... And for anyone who wants proof of who I am and where I grew up.... 21 Rever Road, Tewksbury / Tewksbury Jr. High / Tewksbury High all have records of my being there, and of my being in art class with John in Jr. High. Before you attack anyone, like jackwad has consistently done... please do a little research.... read what I have said and, if you find a single discrepancy - contact me at my well-posted email addresses. Unlike "jackwad" I have the courage of my convictions and will stand and withstand any test of truth about this... the greatest truth being that "no good deed goes unpunished!"

The editor has closed comments for this article.