patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Columnist George Will Tackles The Motel Caswell Saga

Battle between Tewksbury motel and the Department of Justice is grabbing national attention.

 

The ongoing battle between the U.S. Department of Justice and the owners of the Motel Caswell has now grabbed national attention.

No less than Pulitzer Prize winning syndicated columnist George Will has tackled the debate in his latest column for the Washington Post, describing the situation faced by Russ and Pat Caswell as a " a Kafkaesque nightmare unfolding in Orwellian language."

The conservative Will blasts the Department of Justice for attempting to seize the Caswells' property for the misdeed of motel guests, when the Caswells themselves have not been accused of any crimes.

Click here for Will's complete column on the Motel Caswell.

Related Topics: Department of Justice, George will, Tewksbury Police Department, and motel caswell

Bill. S

8:40 am on Sunday, May 20, 2012

where did George stay while doing research for his column? I bet it wasnt the Caswell

Reply

Dave

9:22 am on Sunday, May 20, 2012

Gee, I wonder why Tewksbury is so attractive to low life scum: you are what you are!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Joe Bill

10:17 am on Sunday, May 20, 2012

I'm a corporate executive at a company that employs 6000 people and I live in this town. Dave take your single digit IQ somewhere else.

Comment_arrow

Dave

10:36 am on Monday, May 21, 2012

Joe stop whining, seriously everyone else has a low IQ except you, Nice EGO trip!
Does your position with the company entitle you to have a key to the executive wash room?
Do you manage from there?

Comment_arrow

Dave

7:42 am on Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Joe and Steve two big brains with that said but, no common sense. Remember one pant leg at a time. Goofs

beatrice

11:11 am on Sunday, May 20, 2012

The picture of the Motel Caswell in this article is a telltale indication of the downfall of this establishment, as well as the Motel 6. When you rent a room by the week, at this rate, what type of clientele do you hope to attract? As a longtime Tewksbury resident, I am amazed that there have only been 30 drug arrests since 1994. This motel and Motel 6 were used for years to shelter homeless people. If you were to drive into town on a warm summer afternoon and see the class of people sitting outside the Caswell rooms, you would continue to drive by with a look of horror. Sorry, but the average person would not feel safe falling to sleep in one of those rooms. If the Caswells expect us to believe that they had no idea what was happening at their motel, then they aren't very good at managing a business. They should have invested some of their profits back into their motel before it became so run down. It is a shame that it had to come to this, but it didin't happen over night.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Steve Magplate

10:43 am on Monday, May 21, 2012

This is America, how can you possibly think that taking someones property when they have not been charged with a crime is just or constitutional?

Renee

12:51 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

Maybe instead of shutting the place down they can see if the people want to get out of that live style and realize they don't have to live a life of drugs and crime. If they shut this place down these people will have no where to go. They probably are on food stamps as it is. I feel like a lot of people are playing out of sight out of mind. Even if you close this place the people are still going to exist just exist without a place to sleep. Everyone states that it makes Tewksbury look bad. Question to all of you, do you think Tewksbury will look better if these people starting sleeping in the streets or the park benches like they do in the city??

Stop trying to fight against this and work with it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bill. S

5:58 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

answer: no I think maybe you should take them all in and give them a place to sleep. then Tewksbury would look better

Comment_arrow

Renee

10:52 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

see funny Bill that is the point I am getting at. people are quick to make statements on how we need to get rid of this place it makes Tewksbury look bad. But they have to go somewhere they don't just poof away with the place. But of course you try to make a snide remark to my question because you are not the one in their shoes. I can't imagine what some of their lives are like. and we are so quick to shoo people away. cold hearts don't solve problems they just freeze them over for the time being.

Michael Adams

1:27 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

Thought this might help here......"I suppose you could fine local Hotel/Motels... for every drug offense that takes place on the property that ends in an arrest, oh I dont know... say $5000.00 per incident? Every attempted murder or battery, ah, say, maybe $10,000 per incident... It works when it comes to serving minors, and incidents at places that have licences to serve alcohol. Every now and again a Liquor license is suspended, revoked etc..... I believe there is such a thing as a Inn Holders' License. Im not a big fan of "Big Brother"either , but I'm also not a fan of miscreants who stay in hotels in lieu of a residence on my dime and most likely use more taxpayer funds to purchase drugs, prostitutes.. etc, again...on my dime and then end up in the local news arrest log. nobody asked....just my opinio

Reply

Gordon Pickguard

1:31 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

I haven't read the article, however that has never stopped me form bloviating beyond my level of expertise. Tell me why we should care about any that George Will has to say ? He is so divorced from main stream thinking that it's beyond me how anyone can take him seriously,yet ABC continues to allow him to embarass himself every Sunday morning. OK now that I've taken a whack at old George I think I'll read his article.

Reply

Bill. S

5:24 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

What George wrote is really not a news column. It was more like a biased opinionated blog. 30 arrests for drug dealing? how about the total number of calls to police since 1994. how about the number of times that I have had helicopters hovering the woods in my backyard looking for someone who ran out of there. I bet george doesnt know or care about any of that. How do these people (caswell) sleep at night? is the money that good? I dont agree with taking property but would like to see the place shut down and leveled.. Caswell could sell the property or do whatever he wants with it but get rid of the motel

Reply

Bill. S

5:53 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

I (think) what Dave is saying is that the Caswell gives low life scum a place to be, and as long as it is here, they (low life scum) will be attracted to tewlsbury. A few years ago I met a Tewksbury cop (while golfing) who made a comment about the Caswell. He said that Lowell is a giant cauldron of S#@T that tilts and overflows into Tewksbury sometimes. When it does, he said we go to the Caswell, round them up and send them back to Lowell. The place attracts a bad element and I dont know how an owner could not see that.

Reply

Carlos

8:40 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

I feel most of you that are posting here are making valid arguments for cleaning up your town, but missing the real reason that this article was written. The Town of Tewksbury and the Federal Government are in cahoots to take away someones property that they worked hard to pay off. Like the article states: "This would not be happeneing if the property had a huge mortgage." If the town were interested in cleaning up the town, the town would have done something about it long ago. If the Caswells had not paid property taxes, I could understand the lawsuit. Please dont tell me that you want my property if I follow your laws. Just my humble opinion

Reply

Gordon Pickguard

8:56 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

If Caswell is operating outside the moral and ethical standards of Tewksbury we can enforce or create zoning,health regulations ect. that will crush his operation. Is it just happenstance that Andover or Wellesley looks the way it does ? NO ! They have regulations that reflect the good taste of it's residents. Do they have better taste than Tewksbury residents ? NO they don't !

Reply

Chris

9:41 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

Like or not like the Caswell, The point is that the US Government and our police department are doing a disservice to the Caswell Family. I hope the Caswell win and win big. Shame on our town and the FBI!

Reply

steve123

9:56 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

TO Mr Caswell,
I'm glad your getting National attention on this matter now, this is how I found out about this matter by reading todays article in Herald. Keep up the fight, this is appalling to believe that this is even a possibility in year 2012. I don't live in Tewksbury, but I do believe that the town has many eye sores, just like most towns. To be honest I think South Tewksbury is more of an eye sore. This isn't even about the Motel its about our rights and if we allow or support this because we don't like the place then we as a country will all be at risk. For example, if I work hard and purchase investment properties and one of my tenants has is involved in illegal activity, that I am unaware of, the government and local authorities can seize my property and take all the profit that I've worked my entire life for. Isn't this still AMERICA wake up people its so much bigger than Motel Caswell, stand up for something before its too late!

Reply

Carlos

10:51 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

I also do not live in Tewskbury. I live in Las Vegas, NV and this article made my Sunday newspaper, so I am sure it has made many newspapers around the country. This is a very important time for the Caswell Family. To think they saved alot of the money they earned from the Motel. Granted, they probably milked it the last few years without putting any money back into it for repairs. Thats the Caswells right and they have every right to do this. The Caswells have not even been accused or convicted of any crime. We dont know if the Town has warned them about the residents, but isnt it the Caswells right to be protected by the police department? If the Town knew of this activity from as far back as 1994, then why have'nt the Police done anything about it. The Caswells have a right to be protected from these criminals also. They provided the police with everything the police asked. So, as far as we know, the Caswells have not done anything wrong and to think the city can come in a scoop up the Motel is proposterous. I smell something bad going on in the city of Tewksbury. The people who live in Tewksbury have every right to be concerned about the people who stay at the Motel, but the Police must protect the Caswells and every citizen of Tewksbury from anything bad going on. It sure does not sound like that is happening to me.

Reply
Comment_arrow

steve123

11:22 pm on Sunday, May 20, 2012

Carlos, I agree 100%, I find it funny that this town is worrying about Little Motel Caswell that probably has little if no effect on their daily lives. They should be more concerned with the schools that are pretty much despicable, not to mention many much larger political battles that are needed there. The police department building there looks like it belongs in a city with a population of 100,000. I just find it very interesting that the police department could stand to gain as much as 80% of this mans life earnings if they win.

Comment_arrow

malcolm nichols

8:50 am on Monday, May 21, 2012

Maybe we should fingerprint all the Hotel/Motel tenants. If i recall our police begged for and we approved in town meeting the other day to fingerprint a certain class of people. Why not fingerprint everyone right now? Except for the illegals, let ICE handle them.

Comment_arrow

Bill. S

3:22 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Carlos, You should stick to things going on in NV. Did you really think that you were qualified to post on this after reading a short, biased, one sided column by this idiot Will.? You ask why the police have done nothing since 1994, I can tell you that they have. I dont think a week goes by with out at least one trip by the police to the caswell Like I said earlier, he should tell us how many times a unit has been dispatched since 1994 not the comfy number of drug arrests (30) but this is all hard to see from 2500 miles isnt it Carlos?

Comment_arrow

Renee

11:09 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

I totally agree from you and I live here. Carlos, please excuse Bill he represent the extremists that post here on tewksbury patch. I just get the daily news because I go to college and I keep up on what is happening in the town. But honestly, you bring up good valid points and this is definitely a problem because they are just looking to point fingers. Motel Caswell on average takes in people who receive low income and with that comes crimes and such in this situation. With that being said people are being close minded here in Tewksbury and are viewing it as "if you can't see it it doesn't exist". More or less like 3 year olds that haven't learned object permanence yet. But anyways like I was saying, I think it just boils down to trying to solve the little crime issue we have here in tewksbury, which it tends to be at Caswell. Thus resulting in them blaming Caswell because they are not doing...exactly so far they haven't done anything wrong, but they are housing the people who commit the crime. SO what I am getting at is that they are trying to hold someone responsible for what is going on.

But like I said the object permanence situation. Ok so what happens if the Caswells do get fined for what has happened there in the past 20yrs then what? shut the place down. those people live on the streets. Motel cawsell could be some families homes for all we know. we can't just ditch them.
but we probably will :/

Comment_arrow

Renee

11:12 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Oh PS Bill so Carlos doesn't have the right to say something because he doesn't live here... Get real! for crying out loud he is from NV so clearly this is news that is spreading fast and is a big concern. Also, this is the Internet and this is a website. All you need to be qualified to post something on the web is an email address and a password. How low are you for telling this man he is not qualified to post an opinion because he does not live here. I would like to see you have the balls to say that to the judge taking this case.

Melissa Gleaton

12:23 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Malcolm - no kidding! That thing passed like a thief in the night.

I can't believe anyone would want their name (their FAMILY) associated with the crap that goes down at the Caswell. I can't fathom any "pride" in this ownership. I just don't see it. However, some people are crazy, and it isn't within the government's rights to come in and take over just because the owner is seemingly oblivious and delusional.

Perhaps there should be a sign out there "X days without police incident" *chuckle*

Reply

Bill. S

3:29 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

There has to more to this story than we are getting. I dont think that TPD woke up one morning and said :"hey lets take Caswells property and then we can sell it" I also find it hard to believe that this would be the first option for solution to the on going Caswell problems. There were no warnings,no talks with Caswell, nothing? All of a sudden, out of the blue, Tewksbury Police and the feds are trying to take someones property.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Carlos

4:53 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Thats right Bill,..... It happens all over the country.....all of a sudden, out of the blue......you are very naive, Bill, or a little immature.

Bill. S

3:34 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Steve 123
If by "little effect" you mean telling your kids to stay in the house while the helicopter searches your back yard for the fugitive who just tried to kill his girlfriend and then ran from the Caswell into the woods. I have to say that is more than a "little effect" and they had to build that police station to house everyone that they pluck from the Caswell

Reply
Comment_arrow

steve123

6:58 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Maybe the Tewksbury Hospital should be closed down too and while were at it maybe all the apartment buildings in town that have constant complaints. Listen Im not saying that there shouldnt be a remedy but to take this families entire family savings while himself never being charged with any crime (including obstructing justice) is by far one of the craziest things I've ever heard of. Like I said earlier this is much bigger than the Motel Caswell, if we allow this as a country we'd all may as well sell our properties because who the hell would want property that the Fed and local police department can come and take along with all the equity. Please think about this logically.

Comment_arrow

Carlos

7:47 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Steve123..... Well said !! I really believe that the citizens of Tewksbury are very concerned about the residents of the Caswell Motel, and they should be. The point Mr. Will is trying to get across is ... what right does the Town of Tewksbury and Federal Govt. have to seize your property in this manner. They evidently DO have the right to do this. So, we as citizens must do something about it. That, I believe is the point of the article.

Comment_arrow

Bill. S

7:41 am on Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Oh come on Carlos, who is being immature now? I never claimed to be an expert on how T.P.D. conducts business. My only claim is living close enough to see what goes on there. All you had to go by was a short one sided column by a guy who doesnt seem to know where he stands Conservative? Liberal? anti government? I dont know. He does write a good baseball book though. In the end Carlos, I am 100% against government seizure of property in fact I thought we were protected from this by the 5th amendment. not allowing confiscation of land with out just compensation. Eminent Domain. Perhaps this is what you refer to as happening all over the country. I would have no problem if the town and or state offered Caswell fair market value and then take the property. The are plenty of quality builders in the area who could buy and develop a stretch of townhomes maybe even low income so that "make a difference" will be happy Or an empty lot would certainly be better than what is there now and Caswell would have his retirement

Carlos

4:48 pm on Monday, May 21, 2012

Ok Bill, You are the expert on how the police conduct their business.... If what you say is true, the police are at the Caswell Motel once a week since 1994, then I am glad that I live 2500 miles away. Also, calling Mr. Will an "idiot" .....are you qualified to call him that? Sound familiar, Bill ????

Reply

Bill. S

4:14 pm on Tuesday, May 22, 2012

So miss Make a Difference, I am an extremist now? Could you define that for me. if it is a person who is not a big fan of having drug and or crime infested motels in my neighborhood then I guess I am.
as far as "having balls" as you so eloquently put it, as long as my comments fall within the parameters of free speech, I will always make them-so will you. telling a judge that he or she is not qualified makes no sense. I am pretty sure that the judge is more qualified than me, you, and carlos put together. Carlos had valid concerns about our government and what power they may have, but the Caswell story is a little more involved than that and has more than one side. Time will tell, Your heart seems to bleed for the people who inhabit the motel, in time your thoughts may change, maybe not. either way good luck to you, and lets hope for an outcome that everyone can live with

Reply
Comment_arrow

Carlos

4:53 pm on Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Bill.... You seem to be a different "Bill" than the one who has posted that last couple days. I dont know if you have taken a step back to look at the whole picture but your comments today, dealing with the situation as a whole, make sense. I will reiterate my point again....The Town and Feds are in cahoots to seize the property of someone who has not even been accused of a crime, because the property does NOT have a mortgage. I assure you that this would not be the case if the property had a 2 million dollar mortgage. The reason I say this, 2500 miles away, is because I have seen it happen here in Las Vegas and other parts of the country. There are Caswell motels all over the country, if you know what I mean. That is why I am very pro-active of this injustice. The Town and the Feds DO have every right to do these things, whether you think it just happens "out of the blue" or not. I totally understand your feelings on the bad elements at the Motel Caswell. That is totally a different issue here..... that is what George Will is trying to tell us. I have never been a big fan of his, but I try to keep an open mind because Big Brother is capable of doing some horrendous things. Lets face it......Do you agree? Thanks for listening.

Bill. S

3:11 pm on Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Hey Carlos,
still the same Bill. i dont like the motel and I think George failed to paint an accurate picture of what has gone on there for years
I also realize the issue is forfeiture laws. Civil forfeiture is defined as: The loss of ownership of property used to conduct illegal activity. Does this apply to the Caswell? no not at all, the owner of the property did not conduct illegal activity, but for years and years and years the owner in this case seemingly sat content. Content knowing full well what was happening on his property during his watch. I know the popular response here would be "What could he do" I dont know but sitting content would not be my option. i believe he should somehow be held accountable. Should he loose his business and property/? NO and that is where the real problem starts. I have no issue with civil forfeiture as defined but it is a problem if agencies are actively seeking targets for financial gain. Carlos, I found a great article on Forbes.com titled "civil forfeiture laws and the continued assault on private property" written by Chip Mellor Anyone with even remote interest in the Caswell case should read this, it is much more educational than the piece by Mr Will

Reply
Comment_arrow

Carlos

5:43 pm on Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Bill.... Great article by Chip Mellor and I highy recommend it to anyone intrested in finding out what "Civil Forfeiture" is and how the Feds and Towns can go head hunting to gain profits. To his credit, George Will gives you a link to access by the Institute for Justice, a Libertarian public-interest law firm. The link can be found in the second to last paragraph of his column. This link gives you actual case by case examples of how the different Towns all over the country have used Civil Forfeiture to their benefit. It will turn your stomach and that is what raised the hair on the back of my neck just like a rabid doberman pinscher. The onus is actually on the owner to prove his innocence which is completely opposite of what we were taught was part of our justice system. It really is a good read ...... I think wew have all stated our feelings on this subject..... I am not sure if anyone is right or wrong here.
Bill, you are upset with Caswell because he turned his head the other way and I cannot blame you for that. But what sours me on this whole situation is: Would the Town aggressively pursue this if the property had a huge mortgage? If the answer is yes, then I have no complaints, but I have a hard time believing that the answer would be yes !!!!

Bill. S

4:13 pm on Thursday, May 24, 2012

Carlos, I have to agree with this. If the monetary gains were not possible, the town may also be content with status quo and the Caswell as we know it would continue on. This case will be interesting.
I do find it ironic though that after years of being attractive to a certain clientele, They are now attractive to the feds.
I apologize Carlos for being hostile towards you earlier in the week. Of course you and anyone else has the right to post

Reply

Carlos

5:18 pm on Thursday, May 24, 2012

Bill.... I enjoyed sparring with you. That is what the foundation of this great country was built on. At least we have a forum to express our opinions, whether we agree or not. I will keep my eye on Tewksbury Massachusetts and hope they clean up that area. By the way, I am familiar with that area. My dad owned a chemical company back in the 60's and early 70's. It was located right behind the Caswell Motel, just over the railroad tracks. You said you lived near there, so you must know where am talking about.

Reply

Sue

6:37 pm on Sunday, June 24, 2012

I unfortunately had the pleasure of visiting one of these rooms at the caswell for state business and this place should be condemned. It was the most disgusting pit, cockroaches should not be allowed to live there. Clearly these people do not care about their property, their neighbors or the town. Why not seize their property and teach them a lesson. Really these fine upstanding owners who rent a room by the hour deserve what they get. They are simply slum lords.

Reply

Steve Magplate

3:19 pm on Monday, June 25, 2012

"Why not seize their property and teach them a lesson."

The British in 1776 and Hitler in the 1930's couldn't agree more with this statement!

Reply

Melissa Gleaton

4:05 pm on Monday, June 25, 2012

But Steve, it's for the children!

Reply

Steve Crane

7:01 pm on Monday, June 25, 2012

I don't think the government should get involved unless Motel Caswell is doing something to threaten public safety.

Reply

Sue

6:10 am on Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Oh look its that respectable establishment which I use lightly and sarcastically, in the news again.

Saturday, August 4

12:09 a.m.: A 911 caller from the office at Caswell Motel stated there was a male beating up a female outside one of the rooms on the property. All cars were sent and one was transported to Saints with an officer on board.

Reply

Leave a comment