patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Town Meeting Vote Means South Fire Station Will Be Open Full-Time ... Maybe

Amendment on the floor of Town Meeting adds $302,000 to Fire Department overtime budget.

 

Anyone wondering about the power wielded by citizens at an Open Town Meeting got a first-hand civics lesson Monday night at Tewksbury High School.

Acting on an amendment brought forth by Democratic Committee Chairman Warren Carey, residents voted 65-62 to add $302,000 to the overtime budget of the Fire Department which, in theory, would provide the department with the staffing needed to keep the South Fire Station open 24 hours a day, year-round.

The money will be transferred from the town's certified free cash, money that had been earmarked toward the purchase of an Elgin sweeper for the DPW and paying off the town's long-term leases on various pieces of equipment. As a result of the vote, Town Manager Richard Montuori said the purchase would be scrapped for now and only next year's leases would be paid off.

Carey's proposed amendment was proposed during debate over the Public Safety section of the budget and came as a shock to most of the roughly 130 residents in attendance on Day 1 of the Annual Town Meeting. Most surprised may have been Fire Chief Mike Hazel who said he could not guarantee that the money transfer would mean South Station would be opened full-time.

"The budget is still fluid. There's nothing I can say that's cast in stone," said Hazel. "Certainly any money helps. It's a matter of seeing where money is placed."

Hazel said he will know more once the state finalizes its budget and official state aid figures are released.

Carey, who does not live in South Tewksbury, said he was proposing the amendment on behalf of the people in that neighborhood.

"If they wont get up to speak about it, I will. Getting rid of the leases is important but its not more important that keeping the fire department open. Our priorities are topsy-turvy here," said Carey, adding that it was up to the residents to decide what their priorities were.

"I'm going to use this as a straw poll," he said. "If you don’t vote to keep the fire station open then I don’t give a crap anymore. Close the stations."

Several residents rose to speak in favor of Carey's amendment, including Joan Dunlevy and Rick O'Neil. Dunlevy spoke about a fire in South Tewksbury that claimed the lives of a mother and her children, years before the South Station had been built and the need to avoid such tragedies in the future.

"We are talking about putting people in peril that is not accepted in any other part of this community," added O'Neil.

Montuori and Finance Committee Chairman Robert Cook spoke in opposition to the amendment. Both men expressed a desire to see the South Station open full time again but said that the budget presented, as is, was an important step in improving the long-term fiscal health of the community.

"I would ask town meeting to stick to the plan, stick to what has been brought forward," said Montuori.

Resident Malcolm Nichols also spoke against the amendment, saying he supported the fiscal responsibility of the budget as presented.

"I see this town spending money it doesn’t have over and over and over," said Nichols. "We just gotta stop."

At first, Carey's amendment was defeated in a standing count, 58-56. However, a short time later, Carey moved that his amendment be reconsidered under procedural error, as the "checkers" who were checking in voters in the cafeteria area, had not been notified that a standing vote was being taken, giving them the chance to come to the auditorium to be counted.

Town Moderator Keith Rauseo acknowledged and apologized for the error and voters approved the reconsideration.

After further debate, Carey's amendment passed, 65-62.

Montuori, showing the ability to adapt on the fly, made some quick adjustments to the free cash section of the budget in the form of his own amendment, which voters approved. A short time later, voters approved the entire $86 million municipal budget.

 

Related Topics: Annual Town Meeting, Mike Hazel, Richard Montuori, South Fire Station, Warren Carey, and keith rauseo

Bee Free

4:15 pm on Tuesday, May 8, 2012

short sighted emotional vote

Reply

Karyn

4:48 pm on Tuesday, May 8, 2012

I agree. The Town Manager is just trying to do his job making sound financial decisions to help us out of the financial hole we've dug ourselves in.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bob Ferrari

3:29 pm on Wednesday, May 9, 2012

This was my feeling as well that night.

Bob Rauseo

6:03 pm on Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Sometimes a "short sighted emotional vote" is exactly what is needed to help those making "sound financial decisions" keep their priorities in line with those of the people they are elected or appointed to serve.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bob Ferrari

3:29 pm on Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Actually Bob, that is a very true statement.

Jon Pratt

8:26 pm on Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Mr Carey's motion was to increase the firemans budget - they can do what they want with it.

Reply

malcolm nichols

2:27 pm on Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Yes a procedural error by the moderator cost the Town over $300k. Many residents left the meeting after the initial rejection vote. It was not until approximately 1 hour after the rejection that the procedural error was identified. Knowing that many residents had already left it was recommended that we postpone any revote until the following Town Meeting date (2 days later) tonight.
The suggestion to delay the revote was ignored.

Reply

Gordon Pickguard

9:22 am on Thursday, May 10, 2012

Well, here we go again. The inbred hicks,farmboys and morons are at it again. Open town meeting exists for them to display their ignorance and stupidity; another reason to change the charter. Long term fiscal health means nothing to those who can't see past the end of their nose !

Reply

Jake Craken

11:14 am on Thursday, May 10, 2012

Who is ignorant and stupid? We are simple voters with a feeling of civic duty. Most voters are not professional speakers, but they try to express themselves as best they can. I applaud the bravery of people that get up to speak as they are subjected to the ridicule of simple-minded people that disagree with them.
"Experience hath shewn, that even under the best forms (of government) those entrusted with power have, in time, and by slow operations, perverted it into tyranny." - Thomas Jefferson

Reply

Melissa Gleaton

3:24 pm on Thursday, May 10, 2012

@Gordon, thank GOODNESS we have scholars like you to tell us what's best for us!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Gordon Pickguard

4:10 pm on Thursday, May 10, 2012

Melissa, I thinks it's usually obvious,but this time I couldn't resist. Management of a multi million $ operation should be left to the professionals,not messed with at the last second by some clown who always thinks he has a "good" idea.

Melissa Gleaton

4:40 pm on Thursday, May 10, 2012

I'm not necessarily a fan of Mr. Carey's politics myself, but you can't fault someone who sees the professionals spending money here there and everywhere on things that shouldn't take priority over public safety. Sure, it may not be "that easy", but when people feel that they aren't being heard, or taken seriously, they need to send a message to the powers that be that WILL be heard. Nobody is going to die, lose their job, lose hours at the senior center, lose hours at the library, due to Mr. Carey's amendment. Could someone die if SOMEONE doesn't do SOMETHING about this fire station? No one offers solutions, they just accept "it is what it is."

Reply

Bob Rauseo

6:22 pm on Thursday, May 10, 2012

Earlier in this thread I expressed a similar sentiment that sometimes the ordinary citizens need to find a way to send a clear message to the "powers that be."
Having said that, I do not think the action taken will have a lasting impact. It was stated quite clearly at Monday's Town Meeting that adding $302,000 to the Fire Department overtime account would NOT guarantee that the South Tewksbury Fire Station would remain open 24/7/365. The action at Town Meeting was a sharp message to Town Officials about priorities, but it is not a long term solution.
It provides additional funds for ONE year only and I doubt it will be seen as a mandate. There is no reason to believe that next year's budget will be any different than this year's.

I believe it would have been far better to have made the proposed amendment clear to the townspeople months before town meeting, and had the type of discussions on TI, Patch, and other venues that we had about the proposed charter change.

It would have been very interesting to have the discussion and vote about the fire station at Tuesday's meeting with more than 600 people. Any vote taken at that meeting coulld have had a significant impact on future prioritis.

Reply

Leave a comment